Tragic Loss and Family Struggles

The “entire world” of Karly Cantrell’s family was turned upside down when she was killed in her Middleton home over a year ago. Since Cantrell’s death, significant milestones have passed for her family, including graduations, birthdays, and holidays, all without her presence.

A Devastating Crime

Levi Isaac Davis, Cantrell’s eldest son, was sentenced after stabbing his mother to death in October 2022. Cantrell, known for her role as the executive director of the West Valley Humane Society, was remembered as a compassionate advocate for both animals and people in need.

Legal Proceedings and Sentencing

Prosecutor Stephanie Morse emphasized the profound and lasting impact of Cantrell’s absence on her family. While the defense argued for a lesser sentence, the prosecution pushed for life imprisonment without parole, highlighting the severity of the crime.

Karly Cantrell

 

Contested Narrative

Davis claimed the attack was unintentional, portraying it as a response to his mother’s aggression. However, doubts were raised about this account, suggesting Davis may have had premeditated intentions.

The Tragic Discovery

Kevin Kline, Cantrell’s husband, made a chilling 911 call upon discovering her lifeless body in their home. The scene was described as one of the most horrific cases by law enforcement officials who responded.

Evidence of Struggle

Autopsy results revealed Cantrell had fought back against her attacker, sustaining multiple wounds indicative of a fierce struggle. Davis himself suffered injuries during the altercation.

Family Turmoil

Prior incidents had strained the relationship between Davis and Cantrell’s family, leading to his expulsion from their home months before the fatal incident. Witnesses recounted a pattern of destructive behavior exhibited by Davis prior to the tragedy.